Welcome to the Game Swill Blog!

My name is Chris. I have been gaming for as long as I can remember. Since I've played more games than I can possibly recall, I thought I'd write down some of my thoughts and opinions on games. I hope that I can help you, the reader, find a new favorite game, or at least an enjoyable diversion for an evening with family and/or friends.

Each entry has several features. There's an Introduction with basic info about the game and a link to the website of the game. There's the Gameplay section in which I give you a brief rundown of how the game is played. Last is the review section, where I give the game a rating and explain why I gave it such a rating.

I encourage people to frequent their FLGS's (Friendly Local Gaming Stores), but I have also provided Amazon Product Links to the product mentioned, if one exists. Please check out the blog's sponsors.

If you would like to advertise on my blog, make a request for a review or offer some feedback, feel free to e-mail me at chris@game-swill.com

Tell everyone you know to read my blog, and
ENJOY!

March 18, 2011

Review: Myth: Pantheons

Introduction

Today's review will be for Myth: Pantheons. It was designed by Brent Keith. It was published and distributed by the Alderac Entertainment Group (AEG). The game is designed for three to six players, and can be played in about 45 minutes according to the box. Myth comes in a small, sturdy box with cards and tokens. No bag is included for the tokens.

Myth is essentially a trump, or trick-taking card game. Due to some production errors, the game is of moderate difficulty. It's possible to learn how to play the game correctly the first time, but if you don't, it's a little frustrating. That aside, it has appeal to many kinds of gamers. If you know someone who has played trump card games like Hearts, Oh Heck or 1000, this offers new challenges because it uses five domains, or suits, and a custom deck rather than a typical 52-card deck. For board gamers, it's a new form of gameplay and new strategies.

Gameplay

Every player chooses, or is dealt randomly, a deity. The players receive a special set of six deity cards that are specific to their deity. Seven mortal cards each are dealt to the players. The Ruling Domain, or trump suit, is determined randomly by setting aside the top card of the Mortal deck. The ruling domain can change between rounds. A city is revealed by turning over the top card of the city deck. Cities, and the followers they come with, are what the deities are struggling over.

The leading player plays a Mortal card which becomes the Leading Domain, or suit, which all other players follow when they play one of their Mortal cards from their hand. If they don't have cards from the Leading Domain, they can play a card from the Ruling Domain. At any time, instead of playing a Mortal card, they can play a Deity card from an appropriate suit. The winning player of each challenge, trick, then takes all the cards from the challenge and keeps them in a separate pile in front of him. The other players then gain a Domain Token. Then all players get the chance to use one Divine Act found on their Deity card or any City cards or Domain Tokens they have in play. When a player wins a challenge and has a number of unused challenge piles in front of him that is equal to the number on the current city card, he takes the city for himself and puts followers on it.

If ever a player has no mortal cards at the beginning of a challenge, or all players pass on a challenge because they have neither a card in the Leading Domain nor the Ruling Domain, the Epoch ends. This means that all Mortal cards, as well as any Deity cards that were played during challenges, are shuffled together and a new hand of seven cards is dealt to each player. A new city is revealed.

The game ends after three Epochs. The player with the most Followers, or Cities in case of a tie, wins.

Review - 2

I like Myth: Pantheons, so I'll have to explain the low score in a bit. First, it's portable. It's only slightly larger than a standard poker deck. Second, it's a more advanced version of trump card games. I like all the extra things you can do. Certain abilities let you draw more cards from the mortal deck, change the ruling domain, and other crazy stuff. While you are limited by the cards you are dealt, there are more strategies than standard poker deck trump variants. Third, the art is good. All the deities are beautifully rendered by one artist, Gonzalo Ordonez.

Why the below average rating then? The game suffers from a few production problems. I'll begin by pointing out that the cheat sheet for the players has a glaring error. There is a significant difference in the meaning of "draw" and "discard." If people don't take note of the difference, it changes the way the game is played. For the record, the correct Death domain powers are in the rulebook.

Another problem has to do with the game tokens. First, they should have included a bag for the tokens. Other gaming companies have included bags in comparable games, and sold them at comparable prices. Second, the tokens need to be more distinct. Each token is around a half an inch in diameter and difficult to see from across your average dining room table. Each of the five token types has different art, but the coloration of the art is the same. Some of the tokens have numbers on them, to represent having multiple tokens, which obscures the art beneath it. There is a millimeter or two ribbon of color around each token. Instead of the barely perceptible color ribbon surrounding indistinct art, I think the designers should have tinted the whole token. They would have been more functional that way. Sorting through all those tokens before or during the game is a drag.

Lastly, the City cards should have had art on them. While I love mythology and anthropology, I'm certainly not an expert on those subjects. While I can imagine pictures of Rome, Athens and Tibet, I have no clue what to imagine Uluru, Samarkand and Kaifeng look like. The art would also give people, who are having trouble learning the rules of the game, incentive to continue playing. On many occasions, I've gamed with people who had trouble picking up a game. When forced to make a decision in the game, they used aesthetics or something entertaining to make the decision, rather then their fledgeling grasp of the rules.

Myth: Pantheons is an interesting spin on the standard trick-taking game. It's not hard to circumvent the production problems. When you need to check rules and abilities, stick to the rule book. Use a plastic snack bag (available at grocery stores), or several small bead bags (available at craft stores) to store and separate your tokens. I'd increase expected game time to about an hour. Once you get past that, what you have is a fun card game. Enjoy!

2 comments:

  1. I have yet to try this. Would like to give it a try with an experienced player. Although, I am more likely to substitute tokens than use markers to color them.

    ReplyDelete
  2. First comment! Thanks Greg! On to my response....

    That's a good idea. I still use the tokens included in the game, but I spend a few minutes sorting them pre-game.

    I'll mention that players receive these tokens, they keep them face down until they're used. The problem arises when they reveal and use certain tokens by attaching them to their cities, you can't really see them from across the table. This leads to one of two things. You either forecast your Divine Acts by asking people questions about their cities ahead of time, or you slow down the game significantly by asking those same questions when your turn rolls around. It slows the tempo of the game, and can become very tiresome.

    I think my comments were directed more at the designers of the game, although I doubt this blog is popular enough to be read by game designers yet. These problems could have avoided with better design. I still contend that it is a fun game. If they repackaged and redesigned the game (no rules changes are necessary; more deities would be welcome), the game would be more successful.

    ReplyDelete