Welcome to the Game Swill Blog!

My name is Chris. I have been gaming for as long as I can remember. Since I've played more games than I can possibly recall, I thought I'd write down some of my thoughts and opinions on games. I hope that I can help you, the reader, find a new favorite game, or at least an enjoyable diversion for an evening with family and/or friends.

Each entry has several features. There's an Introduction with basic info about the game and a link to the website of the game. There's the Gameplay section in which I give you a brief rundown of how the game is played. Last is the review section, where I give the game a rating and explain why I gave it such a rating.

I encourage people to frequent their FLGS's (Friendly Local Gaming Stores), but I have also provided Amazon Product Links to the product mentioned, if one exists. Please check out the blog's sponsors.

If you would like to advertise on my blog, make a request for a review or offer some feedback, feel free to e-mail me at chris@game-swill.com

Tell everyone you know to read my blog, and
ENJOY!

June 10, 2011

Review: Carcassonne 10th Anniversary Edition

Introduction

I didn't actually own my own copy of Carcassonne, so when one of my FLGS's informed me that there was a 10th Anniversary edition with an exclusive expansion, I pre-ordered it on the spot. Carcassonne was designed by Klaus-Jürgen Wrede and distributed by Rio Grande Games. It plays for two to five people in about 60 minutes. The 10th Anniversary Edition comes in a box shaped like one of Carcassonne's legendary game pieces, often referred to as a "meeple," and contains a fair number of little pieces in the form of land tiles and little colored "meeples" for each player.

Carcassonne was the Spiel Game of the Year in 2001, and for good reason. The game is very easy to learn, but is very strategic in execution. Veteran gamers love Carcassonne for its subtle complexity. It's also a great game for beginning or casual gamers. For those newcomers to the gaming hobby as a whole, Carcassonne is one of a few great games to begin your collection with because of its appeal to old and new gamers.


Gameplay

I will break this into two sections. Basic Gameplay will be for people learning about the game for the first time. The Festival will be about the expansion, The Fesitval, that is exclusive to the 10th Anniversary Edition package.

Basic Gameplay

Each player chooses a color and takes all the corresponding "meeples" of that color. The starting land tile is placed in the middle of the board. One person is chosen to go first, and play proceeds clockwise from that player.

The player whose turn it is draws one new land tile from the pile of randomized land tiles. The player then places the tile in any location along the outside of the existing map, as long as that location is legal. The sides of the tiles must match up with the sides they are sitting next to. Once the tile is in place, the player who played it has the option of putting one of his "meeples" on the tile he just laid. That "meeple," depending on how it is laid on the tile, will score points for the player depending on what kind of structure is being developed. Throughout the game, players develop cloisters, walled towns, roads and farms.

As roads, cities, and cloisters are completed, players are scored for completing said structures. When the last tile has been played, uncompleted structures are scored, but some are structures are worth less points for being uncompleted. Then, farmers are scored for supplying to completed cities.

The person with the most points wins.

The Festival

If a player draws one of the ten new Festival tiles, after placing it they have two options. They can place one of their "meeples" on it, according to the original rules of the game. They may also forfeit the option to place a "meeple" to retrieve one of their placed "meeples" from the board.

Review- 4

If the re-release of a game on the 10th anniversary of its creation isn't proof of it's greatness, then read on. I'll try to say something more.

Carcassonne is very simple to learn and teach. Once a person has mastered the basics, thougn, there are many strategies one can master. Farmers can be worth a lot of points, but when you place one down, you lose a playing piece for the rest of the game. Even more complex is the art of stealing farms from someone. It is possible to place one or two other farms and then later connect them to a larger farm, and furthermore into an already existing farm, but it's risky because you draw land tiles at random. Of course if you're willing to share the points with another player, you commit fewer "meeples" to the board.

Carcassonne has an abundance of material to expand the gameplay. The River has an MSRP of $6, and adds a few more tiles to the game without any major changes. The Count is also inexpensive but, in my opinion, changes the way the game is played significantly! The game also has spin-offs, but I'll discuss those in other reviews.

There is only one problem that I've ever had with the game, and there was a simple solution for it. Having one randomly drawn tile to work with every turn can lead to really crappy turns. In fact, I can imagine a scenario or two where a tile wouldn't be able to be played. A while back, one of my friends suggested that we play with a hand of three tiles. Each player plays one tile, then draws one to replace it. It eliminates a small element of the randomness from the game, but not enough to unbalance it.

Carcassonne is a great game for players new and old. It's been out for ten years and new material is still being created for it. It's easy to learn and teach the basics, and fun to master competitively. It's less expensive than most other popular, competitive strategy games. If you don't have a copy of Carcassonne already, the 10th Anniversary Edition is a great box to start with, primarily for its exclusive expansion.

2 comments:

  1. Here is another one that I will pass on every time, given a choice. Although, the speed of play could be appealing, if only two players are involved, there is just not enough going on here to keep my interest. I do occasionally enjoy Carcassone: The City.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like the game - but the idea of a 10 year anniversary just seems silly for a mere 10 tiles. Personally, I think they should have made another big box with all the expansions added in. ANd I do very much agree that this game for 2 players is dreadful. The game really does not provide a good experience unless there are 3-4 players.

    ReplyDelete