Today's review is a blog first. This is the first game requested for review, by loyal reader Greg, and it's for Merchants and Marauders (henceforth, MMs). It was designed by Christian Marcussen and Kasper Aagaard, and distributed by Z-Man Games. The game is designed for two to four players, and plays in about two to three hours.
MMs is a realistic pirate board game. It does away with the fantasy elements common in contemporary pirate multimedia, and goes for something closer to historical piracy. It is possible for a player to win without incurring bounties and the ire of the four nations (England, France, Spain, or Netherlands) that are settling the Caribbean, where the game takes place. It is riskier, but potentially more profitable, to attack merchant vessels or even other players and take their goods and gold. You also learn rumors about the location of treasure, or go on rewarding missions for people of importance. I will rate the game as having medium difficulty. I found the rules easy to learn and intuitive, but the game does have a moderate amount of rules to learn, and little pieces to push around the board.
Gameplay
Gameplay
Until your game group is familiar with the game, setup is a bit complex. I'll try to simplify it as much as possible. First, separate and then shuffle all the decks of cards, except for the ships. Lay out a merchant vessel marker, face down, in each of the seventeen areas of the board. Lay out a special modification, face down, and in-demand good, face up, in each of the sixteen ports of the board. Each player then chooses a captain at random, chooses one of two starting boats, and places said boat in his starting port.
Players can perform three actions on their turn. They may perform any combination of actions chosen from the following: move, scout, or port. They can do more than one of the same action on a turn, e.g. three Move actions, Move-Scout-Move, or Port-Move-Scout, etc. I will give a basic description of each.
Move actions are fairly self-explanatory. Moving into or out of a port is an action. Moving to an adjacent sea zone is an action.
Scouting is done in one of two circumstances. There are some Rumors or Missions that require you to make a scout action, and they say so explicitly on the card. The other use of scouting is for piracy. You may choose to raid a ship as an action. They can be simple (mostly) defenseless merchant vessels, Navy vessels of the various nations, or even other player ships.
A Port action is performed in one of two circumstances. The first, like Scouting, is when a rumor or mission tells you to perform a Port action. The second, and more common, use of the Port action is to do Port Activities once per turn. Port Activities represents a lot of small duties that a ship would typically perform when docking. They sell their goods for profit, buy new goods, hire new crew, get repairs, chase down treasure Rumors, claim a Mission, etc.
The first person to get ten Glory Points wins. How does one gain Glory Points? There's a list of different things that give you Glory Points. here are some examples: Complete a Mission, Sell 3+ in-demand goods in a town where they are in demand, Find a Rumor to be true, Buy a Frigate or Galleon, etc. Throughout the game, players keep gold on their ship. When they are doing Port Activities in their home port, they can stash that Gold. The importance of this is that every ten gold you have stashed gives you a Glory Point. The catch is that your opponents don't know about these Glory Points. If you get your sixth Glory Point and you have 40 gold in your stash, you can stop the game and declare yourself the winner.
During the course of the game, a player's captain can die, usually as a result of naval combat. When that happens, the player loses everything but their glory points and gold in their stash. Their starting gold comes out of their stash, with the bank making up any differences as necessary.
Review- 4
Merchants and Marauders is a board gamer's game. It is highly strategic, complex, partly dependent on luck, and can take a really long time to play. I count this as a double-edged sword.
MMs has two main roads to victory. One is the Merchant path, which is slow, steady and can definitely win the race. You buy goods in one port, sell them where they are in demand, buy a bigger boat with a larger cargo hold, complete one or two missions, stash some gold and call yourself the winner without ever having to face a row of cannons. Marauding involves raiding merchant vessels and other players' boats, becoming the scourge of the seas, periodically getting shot at by the navies of the various colonizing nations, and sinking most of your money into repairs rather than your stash. It's risky, but man... it's a ton of fun. It's even possible that your marauding captain will die half-way through the game and the new captain you draw lends well to being a legitimate merchant. There's a lot of small pieces to move around the board, and a lot of little cards that can give you cool special abilities.
The game's complexity can also be its greatest drawback. First, the game takes some time to learn. Once you are familiar with the rules, they're fast and intuitive. It's still a bit of a hump to get over. If everyone knows how to play the game, the game can be played in under three hours. If you're playing with newer players, it's almost guaranteed to take longer.
The game also has a lot of random elements. There's plenty of dice to be rolled, and six randomized decks of cards: Captains, Events, Cargo, Missions, Rumors, and Glory. This promises plenty of opportunities for good or great luck, and just as many opportunities for bad or horrible luck.
To sum it all up, Merchants and Marauders is a rich and complex game. It offers players many different viable strategies with which to achieve victory. On the other hand, the game is not quick, nor is it easy. I'm going to mix a couple of metaphors here and say that MMs is neither an appetizer nor a trailer. It is definitely the main course or the feature presentation, and a great one in my opinion.
MMs has two main roads to victory. One is the Merchant path, which is slow, steady and can definitely win the race. You buy goods in one port, sell them where they are in demand, buy a bigger boat with a larger cargo hold, complete one or two missions, stash some gold and call yourself the winner without ever having to face a row of cannons. Marauding involves raiding merchant vessels and other players' boats, becoming the scourge of the seas, periodically getting shot at by the navies of the various colonizing nations, and sinking most of your money into repairs rather than your stash. It's risky, but man... it's a ton of fun. It's even possible that your marauding captain will die half-way through the game and the new captain you draw lends well to being a legitimate merchant. There's a lot of small pieces to move around the board, and a lot of little cards that can give you cool special abilities.
The game's complexity can also be its greatest drawback. First, the game takes some time to learn. Once you are familiar with the rules, they're fast and intuitive. It's still a bit of a hump to get over. If everyone knows how to play the game, the game can be played in under three hours. If you're playing with newer players, it's almost guaranteed to take longer.
The game also has a lot of random elements. There's plenty of dice to be rolled, and six randomized decks of cards: Captains, Events, Cargo, Missions, Rumors, and Glory. This promises plenty of opportunities for good or great luck, and just as many opportunities for bad or horrible luck.
To sum it all up, Merchants and Marauders is a rich and complex game. It offers players many different viable strategies with which to achieve victory. On the other hand, the game is not quick, nor is it easy. I'm going to mix a couple of metaphors here and say that MMs is neither an appetizer nor a trailer. It is definitely the main course or the feature presentation, and a great one in my opinion.
Thanks Chris! I would probably give it another shot down the road. How does it compare to other Main Course games you've played? Is the time enjoyable? I just felt like it was missing "something" for me to get my pirate on!
ReplyDelete