Welcome to the Game Swill Blog!

My name is Chris. I have been gaming for as long as I can remember. Since I've played more games than I can possibly recall, I thought I'd write down some of my thoughts and opinions on games. I hope that I can help you, the reader, find a new favorite game, or at least an enjoyable diversion for an evening with family and/or friends.

Each entry has several features. There's an Introduction with basic info about the game and a link to the website of the game. There's the Gameplay section in which I give you a brief rundown of how the game is played. Last is the review section, where I give the game a rating and explain why I gave it such a rating.

I encourage people to frequent their FLGS's (Friendly Local Gaming Stores), but I have also provided Amazon Product Links to the product mentioned, if one exists. Please check out the blog's sponsors.

If you would like to advertise on my blog, make a request for a review or offer some feedback, feel free to e-mail me at chris@game-swill.com

Tell everyone you know to read my blog, and
ENJOY!

March 28, 2011

Review: Are You The Traitor?

Introduction

Today's review will be for a different kind of game, Are You the Traitor? (Traitor, henceforth). It was designed by Andy Looney and published and distributed by Looney Labs. This game takes 10 to 30 minutes to play. It can be played by four to ten people. It comes in a small box and contains a small deck of full color cards.

The closest game to which Traitor could be compared is the popular party game Mafia, a.k.a. Werewolf. The players are assigned roles which they must conceal from the other players by bluffing and lying. That is where the similarities end though, as I will describe in Gameplay. This game is not complex or strategic, so it's great for beginning and casual gamers. Veteran gamers' experiences will vary depending on their tastes.

Gameplay

At the beginning of the round, each player is randomly dealt one of four roles: Wizard, Key Holder, Guard or Traitor. Then, the Key Holder is revealed to all players but the wizards. If there are enough players, the Traitors learn who the other Traitors are. The Wizards are then randomly dealt a Good or Evil alignment. All roles are kept secret, except for the wizards whose alignment is kept secret.

One of the key parts of the game is that each role is on the lookout for one specific other role. The Evil Wizard is looking for the Key Holder, the Key Holder is looking for a Good Wizard, etc. Once roles are assigned, the round begins. This is the point where players ask other players questions about their roles and determine whether or not they are lying about their roles. When one person thinks they have found their target, they call, "STOP," and point at that person asking if they are the correct target. If the accusing player is correct, all the players on their side, good or evil, get treasures. If not, the other side gets treasures.

If at any time between rounds one person holds ten or more points worth of treasures, they win the game.

Review - 3

I want to give Traitor a higher rating, but there are some people who are not into this kind of game. While it doesn't have universal appeal, to those people who enjoy bluffing games, it's great and I recommend you get a copy.

Anyone who knows me personally knows that I like psychological games. This game is like poker in that you learn to see through people's bluffs and tell if they are lying. You must also be a good liar or bluffer yourself. I know plenty of people who aren't good at either lying to or reading other people, and consequently don't like this game.

It's a beer-and-pretzels, social game rather than a competitive, strategy game. To me, the most fun parts of the game are trying to pass information to another player without any one else knowing, and silly questions you ask someone when trying to discern their role. It's a great game to play with people you know well, or at least you think you know well.

Lastly, this game is inexpensive and portable. It's cheap and you can carry it in a pocket. What's not to love about that?

Are You the Traitor? is great for people who have played Mafia out and are looking for something different but in the same vein. It's also great for winding down an evening with family or friends. It has bluffing deception, fun and laughs.

2 comments:

  1. I found this game to be enjoyable as far as a concept, but with having as many roles as this game does it can quickly get fumbled around. Though, not a serious game, the amount of side talk that can take place can allow for the game to feel almost "derailed". Though, not a serious game by any stretch, but it does take people to focus on the role they are going to play.

    ~MB

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think that's true of any game, not just this one. This game, being a little more social and freeform, falls victim to that problem more easily. My guess was that, when we played, people just weren't feeling it.

    ReplyDelete