Welcome to the Game Swill Blog!

My name is Chris. I have been gaming for as long as I can remember. Since I've played more games than I can possibly recall, I thought I'd write down some of my thoughts and opinions on games. I hope that I can help you, the reader, find a new favorite game, or at least an enjoyable diversion for an evening with family and/or friends.

Each entry has several features. There's an Introduction with basic info about the game and a link to the website of the game. There's the Gameplay section in which I give you a brief rundown of how the game is played. Last is the review section, where I give the game a rating and explain why I gave it such a rating.

I encourage people to frequent their FLGS's (Friendly Local Gaming Stores), but I have also provided Amazon Product Links to the product mentioned, if one exists. Please check out the blog's sponsors.

If you would like to advertise on my blog, make a request for a review or offer some feedback, feel free to e-mail me at chris@game-swill.com

Tell everyone you know to read my blog, and
ENJOY!

April 1, 2011

Review: Dominion

Introduction

Today's review is for Dominion. Dominion was designed by Donald Vaccarino and published and distributed by Rio Grande Games. It is for two to four players and will take at least 30 minutes to play. Dominion contains hundreds of full color cards, but the box comes with a storing and sorting device built in.

Dominion is a new and innovative take on card games. It's not a collectible card game, like Magic: the Gathering or YuGi-Oh. You get ALL the cards when you buy the box. Instead of building a deck before you play, you build the deck as part of the game. That is why Dominion is commonly referred to as a 'deck building game.' It is a strategic and competitive game. It is easy to play and can be enjoyed by players of all levels of gaming experience.

Gameplay

To setup Dominion, the players lay out all the stacks of Victory and Treasure cards. They might also lay out the Curse cards. Then, ten different stacks of playing cards are chosen either at random, from a themed list of pre-selected stacks, or by player consensus and laid out on the table. The players are each dealt a deck containing three Victory cards and seven Treasures. Players shuffle their own decks, and draw a hand of five cards. Every player will have their own deck of face-down draw cards and a face-up discard pile.

On their turn, a player has three phases. The first is the Action phase, where a player can use one card that has an action on it. These actions allow them to play more actions, draw more cards, give them money, allow them to buy more cards in the Buy phase, and/or other effects.

The next phase is the Buy phase. Using the Treasures they have in hand, players may buy one card to add into their deck. It is possible to buy multiple cards in one turn, if the player used an action that granted them extra buy opportunities.

After the Buy phase, is the Cleaning phase. The current player puts all the cards he played, or not, and bought in his discard pile and draws a new hand of five cards. When a player runs out of cards to draw, he shuffles his discard pile and turns it face down and it becomes his or her new draw deck.

When all the Provinces (a Victory card), or the entirety of three piles, have been purchased, the game ends. The players count the number of Victory points on the Victory cards they bought. The player with the most points wins.

Review- 5

The first thing I thought after playing a demo of Dominion at GenCon 2009 was, "This is so cool!" It was new and different and tons of fun. It might have helped that I won my first game, but there's a lot of reasons to like the game on its own.

Previous card games have several disadvantages when compared to Dominion. There are, of course, games based on the standard 52/54 card poker deck, which just seem limited after you've played them several times. More modern card games generally require players to buy loads of cards in randomized packs. If a player doesn't have enough money to obtain the better cards, they start at a disadvantage. Then the players must learn the rules of the game. Then they must craft a deck from their pool of cards. After all that, they can finally play a game.

Dominion avoids all these problems! You get all the cards you need for up to four players in one box. The main rules take five minutes to learn. Everyone starts with the same resources and has an equal chance to win the game, whether it's their first game or their hundredth. A group of four can begin enjoying the game as soon as they open the box, rather than the days of preparation that most CCG's require. Each game can be different because you can choose a different set of playing cards each time you play.

Several game designers have come to enjoy the deck building mechanic, too. I believe this is evidenced by the fact that games have been created using variations of the mechanic since Dominion had been released in 2008. I can think of at least three popular games, which I intend to review in the future.

One of the most fun aspects of the game is finding card interactions in any given set of playing cards. Players can develop and employ new tactics mid-game. The beginning of the game is always quick because players have few options when it comes to playing one action and buying one card. In the late game though, players might take four or five actions, draw several extra cards, and finally buy a few cards that are more expensive and powerful. Using half of your deck in one turn is more common as the game goes on.

Some of the gripes about the game involve player interaction. First, one player takes their turn at a time. This can lead to lulls in the late game as one player takes two or three minutes drawing and playing more cards if he gets a good starting hand and subsequent draws. I never thought this was a problem, because I enjoy when someone has a good turn as described. I then buy the cards he or she used and hope to have a similar turn of my own. Second, there are cards that mess with the other players on your turn. Some of those cards have been labeled negative player experiences. This is extremely prevalent in the expansion Intrigue. I use the cards as much as the other players do, and accept that it's part of the game. You don't have to play with those cards, though.

"Wait, Chris. Did you say expansion?" I did. There are four. If you feel that you played out the base game, each expansion adds new cards following a theme and sometimes adds new mechanics. You can mix and match cards from all the sets, or play all cards from one set.

Dominion is innovative and fun. Since it's release, it's won several awards, released several expansions and become an instant classic. Check it out, especially if you haven't played any deck building games. If you have played another deck building game, see how you like the original.

4 comments:

  1. I will reserve judgement until I play this, but expansions seems like a synonym for booster pack. Not that I am above buying expansions for games I have several. I know that at least one of the expansions can also be played as a stand alone game, is this true of all the expansions?

    ReplyDelete
  2. The first expansion, Intrigue, has the essential Treasure, Victory and Curse cards necessary to play. It can be bought and played by itself. The other three, Seaside, Alchemy and Prosperity, do not come with the essential Treasure, Victory and Curse cards, and require you to own the original Dominion or Dominion: Intrigue sets.

    Synonym for booster pack? Well...
    Dominion expansions cost a little less than the core game, but come with a full set of new cards. You only need to buy one box. CCG booster packs usually include a total of 11-15 randomized cards, meaning that you have to buy dozens, or hundreds to remain competitive.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It's been a long time since I took a game seriously enough to consider it being competitive, I'm just wondering if their is enough game in the stand alone sets to avoid paying $200+ for a game. I have already accomplished this feat on , more than one occasion and I have to be a little more choosy.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The core set has plenty of replay. There are 25 different cards, aside from the money and victory point cards used in every game. During each game, you choose 10 of them. Each combination offers different routes to victory.

    The expansions add lots of different options to the game. Often, they change the way the game is played drastically. I recommend buying the core set. If you play more of it but want to play with new cards, then get an expansion.

    ReplyDelete