Introduction
Mystery Express is about a murder mystery aboard a European train. It was designed by Antoine Bauza and Serge Laget, and produced and distributed by Days of Wonder. The game is designed for three to five players and plays within 60-90 minutes. The game comes in a sturdy, standard sized box. It has an insert with holes and spaces for all the game's full color cards and tokens.
Mystery Express is billed as, "A Whodunit on Rails." The players take on the roles of one of five different investigators who is trying to identify the who, when, where, why and how of the murder on the train. This game is of easy to moderate difficulty. Beginning or casual players will enjoy that the game isn't extremely competitive and that they are, for the most part, left to their own devices. Veteran gamers will appreciate the deductive elements of a murder mystery and the variety of actions a player can take in one turn.
Gameplay
Players begin by creating small stacks of cards for Modus Operandi, Suspects, Motives, Locations appropriate to the number of players. The time deck stays the same regardless of the players. One card from each deck is taken at random to form the crime and is placed under the board. Players then choose their investigator and receive a random pile of evidence.
On each player's turn, they have a certain number of hours with which to investigate the murder. Each different train car has a different investigative power which uses up a certain number of hours. You are trying to see two of each different evidence card to eliminate it as a possibility.
There are some events that happen throughout the game to keep things interesting. New witnesses come forward with info in the middle of the game. A long, dark tunnel between two cities allows you free peeks at your opponents' evidence. The conductor moves to a different train car every leg of the trip.
The time element of the game is handled differently from the other evidence types. There are three points in the game when the time deck is cycled through by all players. You must learn shortcuts to help yourself learn which time card is missing from the deck.
When the train reaches its destination, everyone writes down their deduction and the answer is revealed. There's a clever and thematic tie-breaking mechanic built into the game. People write down their best guesses in a Telegram before the last turn begins. The number of correct and incorrect guesses are used to determine the winner, and the Telegram breaks ties.
Review- 3
It would be easy, and obvious, to compare the game to the Hasbro classic Clue. Even on the Days of Wonder website, the game is billed as, "an imaginative new take on the classic deduction board game..." For the purpose of this review though, I'd like to review it on its own strengths and weaknesses.
The game's strengths are many. Aesthetically, the game is a treat through and through. Someone I played the game with noticed that the back side of the game board is printed with a small design. While the back of the game board is not used, the attention to detail is appreciated. It's full color throughout and the art is in keeping with the Murder on the Orient Express theme.
The game scales as the number of players change. Each extra player above the minimum three adds one new piece of evidence in each category: one new suspect, one new location, one new motive and one new modus operandi. The end result is that the game experience should be consistent regardless of the number of players.
The events that happen in the game keep it from being too repetitive. The new witnesses, the tunnel and the sudden revelation before the second to last turn 'mixes the pot' enough to keep things interesting. The variety of actions one can perform each turn helps too.
If the game has a downside, it's the learning curve. It's not huge, but it takes a game or two to learn how things work and strategies to not waste your resources. The instruction book does a good job of teaching how to play the game, but it also suggests things to help play the game, like ways to use the evidence tracking sheet, etc. This helps reduce the learning curve further.
Mystery Express is the classic 'whodunit' board game updated. It features new and interesting mechanics, and gives the players a wide variety of things to do on their turn. These innovative mechanics are brought to life in one aesthetically pleasing package. I highly recommend Mystery Express to anyone.
Welcome to the Game Swill Blog!
My name is Chris. I have been gaming for as long as I can remember. Since I've played more games than I can possibly recall, I thought I'd write down some of my thoughts and opinions on games. I hope that I can help you, the reader, find a new favorite game, or at least an enjoyable diversion for an evening with family and/or friends.
Each entry has several features. There's an Introduction with basic info about the game and a link to the website of the game. There's the Gameplay section in which I give you a brief rundown of how the game is played. Last is the review section, where I give the game a rating and explain why I gave it such a rating.
I encourage people to frequent their FLGS's (Friendly Local Gaming Stores), but I have also provided Amazon Product Links to the product mentioned, if one exists. Please check out the blog's sponsors.
If you would like to advertise on my blog, make a request for a review or offer some feedback, feel free to e-mail me at chris@game-swill.com
Tell everyone you know to read my blog, and
ENJOY!
Tis is a shame that you only gave it a three. I think that the game is highly enjoyable except for the fact that it is dang near impossible to figure out all 5 things.
ReplyDeleteI contend that a three is a good rating. I play three-rating games all the time, and enjoy them too. The learning curve is a little bit annoying. I played the game with two new people yesterday. They liked the game a lot and wanted to play again, but still felt that they hadn't figured the game out at the end.
ReplyDeleteDo you find this game more enjoyable than Mystery in the Abbey? It seems there are plenty of differences, do you think having one Clue-like game from Days of Wonder is enough?
ReplyDeleteI haven't played Mystery in the Abbey. I'll have to try it out sometime, and get back to you about your question.
ReplyDeleteI have played both. I do think that Mystery Express is a much more solid game all around and requires a bit more thinking and logic. I found Mystery of the Abbey to be MUCH easier comparatively.
ReplyDelete